Showcasing My Friends-2

(For the second post in this series, for which I have been interviewing people I am close to, I emailed Lokesh a set of questions. His responses have been reproduced here. I hope that you would like the idea and enjoy the conversation. The series is to be continued with other friends as and when possible. Sincere thanks to all readers who commented on and appreciated the earlier post). 

Dharaji, a village facing submergence by Omkareshwar Dam project

It was some fourteen years ago that we finished high school. Lakkhu Bhai Pathak – as most of the classmates called him, was everyone’s friend . Often seated on the back benches, I remember him as a quiet and shy but not so shy student lost in thoughts about everything other than what was being immediately taught. His ‘areas’ were quite varied- international affairs, literature, art, cinema and sports! At least that is what I can recall right now. I could be wrong and Lokesh should excuse me for any exaggerations here J

Having finished school, both of us came to Delhi for higher studies. Lokesh studied Political science (he had to!) and then went for a degree in law. In all these years, the occasions on which we met each other can actually now be counted on fingertips. In spite of such an apparent gap in communication, we have remained so much in touch. Looking at the thinker and the artist that Lokesh has evolved into, I have realized the package of talent and creativity he is. His simplicity and the “I am lost in this world” look that he wears all the time impress me the most. A voracious reader, painter and now an equally accomplished photographer (all the photos in the post are his own!) he is someone who continually chooses to defy most conventions. On the occasion of the new year, it is my sincere wish that Lokesh succeeds in all his ‘out of the box’ endeavours and continue to be the amazing individual and friend he has always been.

Lokesh now lives in Bhopal where his projects-actually several of them- continue to take shape.


Personal Concerns- Thank you Lokesh for agreeing to respond. To begin with, I want to mention to the readers that you recently changed a part of your name. Could you tell us something about this journey- from Lokesh Pathak to Lokesh Malti Prakash?

Lokesh- Adding Malti Prakash required lots of deliberation and overcoming certain hesitations. It required rejecting certain norms and accepting certain others over and above them. To put it straight, what I love most about this journey from Lokesh Pathak  to  Lokesh Malti Prakash is this element of choice and challenge. It’s definitely about standing against caste and patriarchy though it might be symbolic. In a way it is. The fight against caste or patriarchy lies at many levels and that at the levels of symbols (and languages, and names….) is no less important.

It’s also an intimate personal journey of constantly trying to regain myself, to imagine myself in a way I like. Just another milestone of a long journey!

PC- How are you liking Bhopal? How is life over there different from that in Delhi and Uttar Pradesh?

Lokesh- I love to be in Bhopal. Delhi has perfectly imbibed the new culture of the globalised India. It has become monstrous in the process. I know Bhopal is no escape. No place is an escape from this predicament unless it chooses to resist. But still, Bhopal retains something of the charm of its peculiar character.

More than this, my love for being in Bhopal is in a way related to my journey that we talked earlier. It is this particular fact that has made my life different from what it was in Delhi. Personally, Delhi was like a lost decade. In a way it’s like redeeming myself as I could be. It’s not a nostalgic longing for Deoria. It’s more like living and reimagining a lost imagination.

At a rally of Narmada Bachao Andolan in Bhopal

PC-  How do you react to a commonly held belief of our times that the national language- Hindi,  is facing a challenge and therefore is in a state of crisis?

Lokesh- I don’t care about the “national language”. But yes, the language Hindi that belongs to its people more than the nation is facing a challenge. But again it’s not in a crisis because of this challenge. The crisis itself is a challenge. A challenge more to the people than a language. A crisis of a society that is unable to accept anything except English as a language of erudition, status and power. I have nothing against English. I have loved my Shakespeare and Shelley in English. But in India and especially in our Hindi-belt English is not merely a language it is more a power-system. And I am very clear that the Hindi of Bollywood and TV ads won’t change this situation.

PC- In case you feel that to be the case, what was so remarkable about the year that just went by?

Lokesh- Personally, Lokesh Pathak became Lokesh Malti Prakash.

For the world at large, (as) you might have expected. The most remarkable about 2011 was not the crisis of neo-liberal order. That’s a stale story. Capitalism has never been free of crises. What is really remarkable is that we are witnessing the rise of resistance that is increasingly globalising. From the Arab Spring to the Occupy. The resentment is maturing into resistance. I wish in 2012 it turns into rebellion.

PC- Which book have you been reading these days? How are you liking it?

Lokesh- Most recently I started reading Hind Swaraj. I am still reading it and I love my disagreements with this marvellously frank book by Mahatma Gandhi. Though my disagreement over specific prescriptions of Gandhi do not preclude me from agreeing with some general principles I am able to discern from what I have read till now.

There is one thing called civilization, there is another thing called modernity and there is a third thing called capitalism. Privileging Marx over Gandhi I would argue against capitalism retaining modernity and civilisation. At the same time, privileging Gandhi over Marx I would argue industrialism as the means of developing the ‘productive forces’ of human society has long outlived its utility and is now threatening life.

PC- Please tell us something about your favourite artists. Who among them impresses or inspires you the most?

Lokesh-This is a very long list. There are painters, poets, writers, film-makers. To name a few….Chittaprosad, Monet, von Gough, Rivera, Picasso, Cartier Bresson, Yeats, Muktibodh, Mayakovski, Kumar Gandharva….

It’s very difficult to say what impresses or inspires me. It can be the beauty, the aesthetics of expression, the politics of expression, desire, nostalgia, love……

PC- You are passionate about photography. In what ways do you consider the photographic image to be significant?

Lokesh- I love the medium of photography. For me the photographic image is significant just like any other image. There is one peculiarity though, the certain tension in the photographic image between the apparent factual depiction (of what was there at a certain point of time) and the loaded interpretative subjectivity that it can’t avoid.

From the same rally in Bhopal

PC- What are your views regarding the need of the institution of an ombudsman in India and the movement led by Anna Hazare?

Lokesh- The movement led by Anna Hazare has obfuscated the issue of corruption in its thoughtless hyper-nationalism with reactionary right-wing leanings. An institution like ‘ombudsman’ might be suitable for checking corruption in a legal sense. But what if corruption is endemic to the system …. I mean it’s structural and beyond scope of ‘ombudsman’. We have had an activist Supreme Court at a point of time. But it could not save the system. Can the Lokpal do anything if the Parliament passes an act privatising the water resources of this country? At best the Lokpal will ensure that this is done without the need of anyone bribing the MP’s.

Anna’s movement is reactionary also because it has raised this hoopla at a time when the market driven policies of governments are increasingly being challenged and resisted. It’s a good safety valve. If the government is not listening it is not because of any revolutionary potential of the proposed Jan-Lokpal it’s only that they want to save their necks.

PC- What are your plans for this year? 

Lokesh- Read, write and shoot!

PC- One event from school days that you are reminded of- mention it here 🙂

Lokesh-Pandey sir, maths, Mrs. Sakhuja, chemistry, physics, Mrs. Ifat, samosa-wale bhaiyya, our cycle journeys!

From my ancestral village Sajaon

(All comments and suggestions regarding the format and the presentation of the interview would be deeply appreciated. Friends who wish to be included in this series, please let me know. It would be lovely to have you here on my blog. Cheers!)


12 thoughts on “Showcasing My Friends-2”

  1. I’ve never been to India, but I’ve always wanted to visit. Very interesting article. I liked the photos too. I’m a little curious what your friend looks like though. Thanks for posting.

  2. Putting my two cents here …
    A valid concern expressed. Dam construction draws stern reactions amongst supporters as well as agitators. Yes there are sentiments attached to every material thing but again we have sacrificed a lot to achieve our freedom & on the same line progress may seek its own share. We definitely don’t want people’s lives to be unsettled and am a firm believer that affected people should be overcompensated. We have seen a quantum leap in Gujarat’s agricultural productivity to an extent that even opposition is singing praise. Mainly thanks to the Narmada Canal network. Looking at the progress I feel we missed out a lot agitation instead of finding a middle ground. To my knowledge enough efforts have been made by Guj. Govt to address rehabilitation issue and if there are still qualms I believe Mr. Modi will be more than happy to hear and address them.
    No I am not a Govt. spokes-person; in fact I am out of the country for almost decade and a half. I just like to admire progressive things open minded. I know you only posted couple of pictures and I blabbed a lot. Ascertains what I said in first line.
    Accolades to your friend for addressing two major issues very well. Language and cast, two issues that has plagued politics and hindering growth to some extent. I’ll express more on that some other time. Responses from Lokesh are the best so far in this series of posts. Convey my best to him.

  3. I like this idea!
    I mean the idea of picking on a friend and getting him to answer a carefully selected set of questions.
    This format can be used now and then for a change.

    To lighten the reader’s experience, and also introduce some fun I suggest you round off the interview with a rapid fire round.
    I suggest that you ask a few provocative questions which must be answered preferably in a single word or at most a sentence with not more than ten words.

    (Your new reader)

  4. It is the characteristic of 2011 people’s movements that unlike any 20th century modern movements they had no comprehensive take on life. There are no ideals in life or cosmos they are articulating. They have very focused albeit ‘short sighted’ goals of corruption or governance etc more often than not very contradictory ideological stances are coming together. Unlike the 20th century idealist movements, of which these governments are a product incidentally!, these are apprehensive a total comprehensive change. I don’t think Anna’s movement has a proper understanding of corruption itself, leave alone tackling the issues of nepotism etc. But imagining comprehensive change, movements seems to have more problems than we think. To me it is a period of creative tension and a lot of confusion, interestingly not as much violence as compared to those modernist struggles. But as long as we learn from our past mistakes it is useful. That dosen’t mean modernist movements agendas are over or are necessarily futile. It is just that one has to be more introspective of things.

  5. Hi PC, i really like the concept of your post. Congratulations to Lokesh for continuing to be unique in his perspectives and not giving in to the rat race. I’m curious to know more about his new name..more about the significance of “Malti”.

  6. I like the concept you have run with recently. Posting other’s opinions is a nice way to learn a bit more about your area and really makes a blog read super fresh. Nice job on it.

  7. Hi PC!

    I really like this article and enjoy the pictures. Never been in India, but I wish hard to visit India. I’m learning Hindi as a hobby 😀 I like the culture and everything about India 🙂 thanks for sharing! Have a great day 🙂

  8. Your Blog made my Sunday. Thanks for that.
    I liked this Q&A post. I liked Lokesh’s views on Patriarchy. It’s courageous, considering the social situation we are living in India, to change the most imporatnt part of one’s name.Please convey my admiration to Lokesh.
    Will have to come back here to check out the whole blog in leisure.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s